There are five children in this photograph, a still gleaned from a 1969 8mm home movie. I am the tallest, and am standing on the far left. My brother John Kennedy Miller, known at that time as “Jay,” stands next to me. My younger brother Allen Michael Miller is in the middle, and my sister Brenda is fourth in line. The fifth child, Diane Wood, is my cousin; she has taken her first baby steps. The elderly gentleman arranging all of us in a row is my grandfather, Charles L. Bragg.
This was 1969, just before Christmas. A few months later, there would be no more smiles.
February 20, 1970. I was on my way home from first grade classes at Clarksville Elementary School (or as I derisively refer to it, #2 of the 12 elementary schools I attended from 1968 to 1981). The bus dropped me off in front of my grandparents’ house on Kenwood Avenue in Slingerlands, where I and my brothers and sister lived while my mother was in the process of getting her life back together and getting involved with the bum who would eventually become my stepfather.
I walked in the unlocked house, and no one was there. I called out for my grandfather, for my younger brothers Jay and Allen, for my younger sister Brenda. No one was home.
No one’s home? Good for me, I get to watch Batman on Channel 6 at 4:00 and no one can disturb me. I was tired of seeing the first part of each cliffhanger episode and missing the second part because someone in the house wanted to watch something else.
But just as the episode was about to air, something odd happened. Family members came over to the house – lots of them, my aunts and other relatives – and all of them seemed very upset over something. My grandmother came home early from her state worker job, and she was visibly upset, to the point of tears. Something was up. I was told to turn off the television and go upstairs to my bedroom until further notice. Oh man, I thought. I was going to miss Batman again.
I did as was told, but instead of going upstairs and to my room, I listened from the hallway at the top of the stairs.
“How fast was he going?”
“I don’t know.”
“Has anyone gotten a hold of Paula yet?”
“I’m trying now.”
“What about Charlie, how much does he know?”
“I sent him upstairs. We’ll tell him later. The less he knows about it right now, the better.”
It was February 20, 1970, a chilly Friday afternoon. For some reason, my grandfather needed to go somewhere that day, so he packed my younger siblings into his car and he drove off. I was at school at the time, but because Jay, Brenda and Allen were too young to stay at home unattended, Grandpa took them with him.
My grandfather was a maintenance worker for the New York Central and PennCentral Railroads, working in the 1960’s at the Selkirk railyards. I remember stories about how, because he was working in Selkirk while his children – my mother and three aunts – were still living on Boston’s South Shore, they received free railroad passes from Boston to Albany so they could visit him as often as they wanted.
By 1970, however, my relatives had moved away from the South Shore, and were living in a small house in Slingerlands.
At this point, I am only able to reconstruct what happened due to family recollections and newspaper reports of the time.
At some point in the afternoon of February 20, 1970, my grandfather – who I think was driving a big gleaming Ford Galaxie 500 at the time, was driving on US Route 20 in the Town of Nassau when he missed a turn, skidded along Route 20, and smashed head-on into a tree.
Grandpa survived the crash with only a scratch on his forehead. My siblings were not so lucky.
Jay was in the back seat at the time of impact; he went flying from the back seat and landed face-first into the dashboard radio. For a very long time, he would have the circular imprint of the volume dial and radio station push-button controls on his cheek. He would survive.
Brenda was in the back seat at the time of impact; the impact jostled her out of her seat and she landed on her back. She underwent treatment for a back injury. She would survive.
Allen was in the front seat. The impact and speed of the crash – and the fact that he wasn’t wearing a seat belt – caused him to fly through the windshield. The Times-Union, reporting the accident in their newspaper, listed his condition as critical, and that he and Brenda were taken to Albany Medical Center. The Troy Record noted that the Nassau Rescue Squad took both Allen and Brenda to Albany Med, and that another company towed what was left of the car away.
Allen spent the next five months at a hospital, never moving, never opening his eyes, never waking up. The family prayed. God wasn’t listening. Less than six months after the accident, Allen Michael Miller breathed his last on August 2, 1970.
It was determined at the time that my grandfather, who never met a bottle of Cutty Sark he didn’t like, was driving with ability impaired that day. Let’s not sugar-coat it. He drove drunk and he killed my brother doing it. But in 1970, seat belts weren’t mandatory. My grandfather’s car didn’t have shoulder belts, and if he had a few nips here and there before getting behind the wheel, what was that, a misdemeanor? Was there any sort of field sobriety test back then, a blood alcohol content meter, anything like that? Or was public drunkenness in 1970 confined to comic appearances on television by Foster Brooks and Otis Campbell? No way to know. I pursued a FOIL request to the State Police (who would have patrolled US 20 at that time) turned up nothing. No records were saved by the Town of Nassau, the Village of Nassau, the fire department, the Nassau Rescue Squad – nothing.
Of course, searching for records from a 40-year-old accident are about as difficult as assembling a jigsaw puzzle with all the pieces facing down. As I researched what happened to my brother after that horrible 1970 car crash, I contacted the Albany County Bureau of Vital Statistics, hoping to acquire a copy of his death certificate.
Unfortunately, not being Allen’s father – or his son – or the executor of his estate – I would need to wait ten more years, until February 20, 2020 – before the 50-year statute of limitations ran out on the release of death certificates. They told me I should contact the hospital where he was staying and ask them to ask the Bureau of Vital Statistics for the death certificate.
“Well, I’ve already asked Albany Medical Center for the information, but they need a death certificate to release that info to me.”
“Did you say Albany Medical Center, Mr. Miller?”
“Yes.”
“That’s not the hospital we have on record.”
And at that moment, I found out something very sad. While Allen was at Albany Med from the time of the accident – February 20, 1970, where he remained in an unconscious, vegetative state for five months – he was later transferred, on July 15, 1970, to St. Margaret’s Center for Children. A short trip up Holland Avenue, with a right turn at Hackett Boulevard.
After speaking with a records access officer at St. Margaret’s, she explained to me what happened during that time. St. Margaret’s in 1970 was essentially a comfort and nursing center for infants and children in their final days of life, essentially palliative care; it also helped place the babies produced by “wayward mothers” – the records access officer’s words – in foster care. Allen stayed at St. Margaret’s, never regaining consciousness, until he finally passed away two and a half weeks later. There was no talk of euthanasia or dying with dignity in 1970 – you went when God called you, not a day sooner.
Today, St. Margaret’s is part of the Center for Disability Services, an organization dedicated to providing care and support for the handicapped, the disabled and the developmentally challenged. I wish the best for the hospital and its goals.
But I still need some answers.
Those answers came from one of the funeral directors at Applebee’s Funeral Home on Kenwood Avenue in Delmar. According to their records, Allen Miller’s funeral service took place on August 5, 1970 with calling hours from 6pm to 9pm, and a prayer service at 8pm. Allen was buried at St. Agnes Cemetery – in, as he confirmed, a little white coffin. The funeral cost $437.72 at that time. From there, Allen was transported to his final resting place, St. Agnes Cemetery.
The accident, the funeral and the wake – and the after-effects – wrecked my family. It was one of the last times my biological father would be seen with my mother’s side of the family, as he drove from Massachusetts to attend the funeral and the burial. He had very few kind words to say about what happened. Very few words at all. And then he went back to Massachusetts and I wouldn’t see him again for at least another decade.
In a twisted version of “protecting the perpetrator,” we were never allowed to bring up the accident in Grandpa’s presence; it was considered too painful and Grandpa didn’t need to be reminded of this terrible accident. I remember such an incident a few months after the funeral, when I asked about Allen, that one of my aunts actually spanked me – to the point of near-welts on my rear end – and told me never to mention that name in front of Grandpa ever again.
Seat belts were in cars in 1970, but they were more lap belts than anything else – and their use were optional at that time, rather than required. Even the baby car seats used in that era barely protected a baby from anything weaker than driving over a pothole.
My mother was forever traumatized. She could never get the image of a little white coffin out of her memory. And many years later, when my 18-month-old cousin Tabitha Deming was killed in a horrible accident, an accident that forcefully reunited the family once more, my mother could not attend the funeral – she told me she didn’t want to see another little white coffin ever again. My mother took this pain with her until she passed away in 2006 – nearly 36 years to the day after Allen’s passing.
In the mid-1980’s, my grandparents moved out of the Slingerlands home and bought a small house in Cobleskill. In 1987, my grandfather passed away after a long battle with emphysema. On the way back from his funeral, I visited the Cobleskill house and went into the attic, looking for something, anything, to remember my familial past.
Then I found it. A collection of 8mm home movies, all stuffed in a box. I grabbed the box and walked out of the house with it, putting it in a car for the trip back home – with the promise that I would duplicate all the films to VHS tape and give copies to any family member who wanted one. Among the film clips in the box were vacation photos, Christmas pictures, scenes from my aunt Isabel’s wedding, a parade in Delmar with all the fire trucks from the Delmar-Elsmere-Slingerlands area – and a few short fragments of film, with my grandfather proudly staring at his five grandchildren.
It’s one of the only fragments of proof that our family was together.
Allen currently rests at St. Agnes Cemetery in Albany. It’s hard to find his grave; at the time, the family did not have money to put a marker or a gravestone on the site. 40 years later, I still need to avail the services of the cemetery caretaker to help find his grave; and even then, I’m not sure if I’m visiting his plot or someone else’s.
My goal for 2010 is to eventually put a simple marker on Allen’s grave, in an effort to finally, after 40 years, bring closure.
Wish me luck.
UPDATE: on December 8, 2010, the marker was installed. Read here for more information.
My heart broke for you upon reading this. I completely understand your need to put some kind of marker on Allen’s grave. I will pray for you.
LikeLike
Thanks for sharing your story. It’s hard to imagine how this tragedy couldn’t devastate any family.
LikeLike
Wow, Chuck. This siory was heart-wrenching to me, and I thank you for sharing this terrible story. This is one of the reasons I don’t drink and alays wear my sealtbelt.
LikeLike
So sorry for the devestating loss your family suffered.
LikeLike
Hours after reading this post, it still haunts me. I hope that you are getting through this sad anniversary okay.
LikeLike
So sorry for your loss. It takes a mighty set of stones to put this sort of thing out in public, man.
My brother would’ve been 26 this coming September 21st. One warm summer day he rode his bicycle up to the top of the cliffs of Thacher Park. As I worked my summer job washing dishes in the restaurant at Jiminy Peak the night of July 30th, 2004, he surrendered after a long war with depression and leapt 120 feet to a tragically early death. It had a similar strain on my own family, blowing open long-simmering tensions. To this day some of them still don’t talk to each other. What-ifs are scant comfort, but if he’d seen the anguish of the hundreds that poured out for his memorial service later that year, I like to tell myself that he would’ve had second thoughts.
Good luck, Chuck.
LikeLike
Chuck, the staff of St. Agnes Cemetery is here to help you in any way we can. I will keep Allen in my prayers.
LikeLike
This story is absolutely heartwrenching, bringing tears to my eyes. I’m so sorry for your loss – of your sibling, of your family’s pain and I hope your goal is realized. Thank you so much for being so brave in sharing this story.
LikeLike
Thank you for sharing this.
LikeLike
Chuck, Which Batman episode was it?
Was it “I’ll Be a Mummy’s Uncle”?
I loved that episode. Adam West deserves way more credit than he seems to get by today’s standards.
People today don’t seem to understand what acting is really all about. It’s no wonder why bit players like Eli Wallach end up owning movies like “ghost writer” based on the fact that they are better actors than the manufactured stars of the films.
LikeLike
Chuck, only an amazing writer could document such a painful family tragedy in this manner. Thank you for sharing a part of your soul. Not sure what planet the writer of blog number 10 is from???
LikeLike
Thank you for sharing this with us. People truly do not always understand the risks and seriousness about drinking while driving and its devastating aftermaths.
I’m sorry for your loss, but I also hope stories like yours spread the word to get people to think before getting behind the wheel.
God bless.
LikeLike
Chuck,
I stumbled across your blog entry and was touched when I read it. As you know, your brother died shortly after I was born and I have no recollection of him. However, I can confirm the family silence of the event. This taboo of discussing the circumstances of Allen’s tragic death was unsaid, but we children all instinctively knew not to. You tell the story quite well, however your story isn’t complete.
Using our grandfather’s name in public should compel you to complete the story by describing his actions after the event. There is no doubt of his responsibility in this tragedy, but you didn’t inform your readers about how he took responsibility.
Our grandfather spent every possible minute by your brother’s bedside during those agonizing months before his death. Members of our family told me that it took nearly two years for our grandfather to control his alcoholism. But he did. Long before 12 step programs or other service he became a recovering alcoholic. As a person who has seen addiction up close, I know how difficult that is and how determined one needs to be to succeed. I have no memory of him ever having a drink. Additionally, he spent years as your brother John’s (Jay) guardian. I can personally attest to the amount of care and protection he provided John.
As for me, there was no greater influence in my young life than grandpa. I remember our grandfather as a strong, honest, caring man. I agree he had tragic flaws, but there is no one I respect more, even now looking through the lens of a middle aged father.
Our grandfather was an alcoholic who is responsible for the tragic death of a young innocent boy. He was also a good man who did his very best to overcome his significant personal flaws. I think should finish the story.
LikeLike
Chuck,
After all this time how dare you bring this up again. Isn’t once enough. Yes Allen’s death was tragic. But bringing this back up is stiring these feelings back up. My mom is all upset about this. Grandpa was a good man. You need not to bad mouth him after all this time. People who have addictions need help not the crap that you just said. If it wasn’t for grandpa taking you in. He did alot for you guys. Even though he has had his troubles with drinking he was a good man. He did alot of good for all of us. DON”T EVER DISRESPECT GRANDPA AGAIN! If it wasn’t for grandpa getting me to do excerises to help with my CP. He took the time and patients to do all what he did. Let him in peace.
LikeLike
Well said Brian, very well said.
Chuck,
I wish I had the chance to know Allen. I’m sure he was a special boy and it is unfortunate that his life was cut so short by such a tragic accident. Although I know the details of the accident to be true, they were once difficult for me to believe. The Grandfather I remember was, as Brian said, a strong and caring man. I remember him as a man who never drank but did as much as he could for his family.
I was fairly young at the time of Grandpa’s death and the memories I have of him, I hold onto dearly. I remember him and Grandma taking me to, and picking me up from camp when no one else could. I remember too, the gifts that he made for all of us kids when we were young. A lot of love went into those gifts. The memory that certainly has had the biggest impact on my life is that of the words of encouragement I received from him to do as much for myself as I could. If there was an obstacle in my way, he pushed me to adapt to overcome it. I am who I am today because of those words of encouragement and his relentless energy.
Although I was not alive at the time of the accident, I am still able to take away from it a major life lesson. Everyone makes mistakes; it is what we learn from those mistakes and do with that new knowledge that truly makes us who we are. Grandpa certainly took responsibility for and learned from his grave mistake. That to me made him not just a strong caring man, but a brave and wise one as well.
I sympathize with the loss of your brother. I can’t imagine what it was like to lose a brother so young and then not be able to fully process that grief. Know that although it was not talked about often, others in the family share your grief in the loss of Allen. I do wish you luck in your endeavor for closure.
LikeLike
Tell your story Chuck – it’s yours and yours alone.
LikeLike
Hi Chuck so sorry to hear about your brother. No matter what people say, time heals no wounds. I googled my birthday and came across this article. I was born 3 02 in the afternoon on 2/20/70. My sympathy for you and your family. Allen will always be alive as long as people remember and talk about him. Take care and god bless.
LikeLike
Not a bad story Chuck. I still have no idea why you have to bad mouth our Grandfather. He was a good man who made a horrible mistake…one that he carried with him everyday after the accident. For your information, your stepfather is far from being a bum…he is a very good man and a great father.
LikeLike
I respect you for telling this, and, as others have said, it is your story and no one can edit. They can tell their own tales, and should. It helps others who’ve had a loss to read what you’ve written.
LikeLike
I too have a family member that rest in an unmarked grave; I know that it doesn’t sit well with my mother or anyone in the family. Once we do mark it I know that my mother and others will feel like they are getting some key closure they are looking for. Wishing you the best in finding what you’re looking for.
LikeLike
Yes, drinking and driving was very much the norm then, not only not out of the ordinary but even an incident like this wouldn’t lead to arrest or charges. And seat belts were pretty new, pretty ineffective, and still disdained by the “real men” who always claimed you were safer being ejected from the car, a most ridiculous failure to understand physics and the limits of the human body. I wish everyone who tells stories of how things used to be in “the good old days” and ends it with “and we’re all still here” could read this. We’re not all still here.
Sad story, kudos to you for telling it.
LikeLike
I know all too well about losing a loved one to a dwi accident, as I lost my mother, your step Aunt, Bonnie. Telling the story is important, however it should be done with grace and dignity. Which for the most part you did, however, how dare you call my Uncle John a bum. He was and still is an amazing man. He would go to the ends of the earth for anyone of us. And he loved you and all of the siblings in an era when stepparents were not known to be that way. And most of all, he made your mother happy and stood beside her til her last moments on this earth.
LikeLike
I’m so sorry about your loss Chuck. This is quite a story, and not many people understand exactly what you went through. Despite Allen’s death, you are extremely lucky, because your other siblings survived the crash. Remember to count your blessings, for you never know how many you will get.
LikeLike